Decoding Proposals: Why the Highest Bid Might Be the Best for Your Project

Discover why the highest-priced proposal from a design and development agency might be the best choice for your project.

Choosing the right design and development agency for your project is a significant decision. After all, when you choose an agency to design and build your project, you’re starting a long-term relationship that may last months or years. After carefully crafting your RFP and meeting with potential agencies, you finally receive proposals. One of them stands out, the one with the highest price tag out of all the proposals you received. When faced with a proposal that’s significantly higher than the rest, how do you proceed?

First, whatever you do, avoid deciding solely based on lower cost estimates without thoroughly examining the higher proposal. This due diligence could save you from challenging conversations about unexpected costs and shifting expectations in the future.

In our experience, disparities in cost estimation are often due to the following:

  • A more comprehensive understanding of the project’s requirements by the agency offering the higher proposal.
  • An aggressive yet realistic appraisal of the project’s complexity by the agency providing the higher proposal.
  • A lack of depth or insight in the lower cost estimates.
  • Anticipation of Unforeseen Challenges: An experienced agency recognizes that RFPs might not capture every nuance or detail of a project. They factor in a margin for the unexpected, ensuring flexibility during the project’s execution without nickel-and-diming you.

It’s essential to examine both lower and higher cost estimates and the context behind them. It’s crucial for your project’s success to understand the differences between the proposals fully.

In-depth conversations with both higher and lower-cost agencies will help to:

  • Confirm the agency’s alignment with your project vision.
  • Understand how the agency would address your concerns.
  • Identify potential gaps in understanding or expertise in the lower proposals.
  • Refine your project implementation strategy based on clarified information.

We suggest starting conversations with the agency that provided the higher proposed cost for the project. A thorough discussion with the agency will help you to understand the reasoning behind their project cost estimation. It’s crucial for your project’s success to fully understand why this quote stands out.

A Roadmap to Facilitate Discussions

Meeting Preparation

Before diving into discussions with potential agencies, it’s important to do your homework. Coming to the table with a clear understanding of your project’s needs and expectations not only demonstrates professionalism but also ensures that the conversation is productive from the get-go. Being prepared minimizes the back-and-forth, streamlines the decision-making process, and helps position yourself as a well-informed client.

Be transparent, genuine, and eager to learn. Clearly communicate your objective to establish a budget that ensures project success and a long-term relationship.

Expressing your concerns prior to the meeting will encourage the agency to critically review your project and come prepared to discuss your queries.

Provide the agency context on where their proposal differs significantly from the others.

During The Meeting

Maintain a sincere, open dialogue and a willingness to learn. Engage actively and consider posing these questions:

  • Could you walk me through the details of your cost estimation process?
  • What happens if the entire budget isn’t exhausted?
  • How do you handle situations where additional budget is required to complete the project?
  • What is your average hourly rate?

Post Meeting

Once you’ve gained valuable insights from the agency offering the higher proposal, it’s equally important to communicate these insights to the agencies that provided lower estimates. A discussion with these agencies can shed light on any differences in their understanding of the project, and it also gives them an opportunity to revise their quotes if necessary.

Meeting with Lower-Cost Agencies

Your approach when meeting with lower-cost agencies should be as meticulous and inquisitive as with the higher-quoted one. Here are some essential questions to consider:

  • Can you walk me through the specifics of your cost estimation process?
  • Are there aspects of the project you see as less complex or easier to implement than I’ve been led to believe?
  • What do you perceive as the project’s main challenges, and how have you factored them into your quote?
  • What’s your contingency plan if we exhaust the budget before project completion?
  • How would you handle any unforeseen issues that might require additional budget?
  • How do you maintain the quality of design and development work within a lower budget?
  • What is your average hourly rate, and how does it reflect in the cost estimate?

Beyond the Bid: Finding the Right Agency Fit

The process of selecting the right design and development agency goes beyond just the numbers on a proposal. It’s about understanding the depth, expertise, and value each agency brings to the table. While a higher bid might initially seem daunting, it may represent a more accurate, comprehensive, and ultimately successful approach to your project. On the other hand, lower bids may offer a price advantage but require a deeper dive to ensure there are no hidden pitfalls. Remember, the goal isn’t to find the cheapest or the most expensive agency but the one that aligns best with your project’s vision, scope, and long-term objectives. By fostering open communication, asking the right questions, and critically evaluating each proposal, you’ll be well-equipped to make an informed decision that sets your project up for success.

Ready to start a project? Let’s talk!

About the Author

Dave Valko

Dave’s got a strong background in film production and it has transferred well to web and software development. Like with any good production, Dave believes in strong planning up front which means clients get a well thought out plan before a single line of code gets written. When not doing CrossFit, Dave also coaches it. Outside of BizStream and CrossFit, Dave volunteers for Scouts BSA as an Assistant Scoutmaster for Troop 292B&G as well as serves as a district Eagle Scout Coordinator, helping young men and women earn their Eagle Scout rank.

Subscribe to Our Blog

Stay up to date on what BizStream is doing and keep in the loop on the latest in marketing & technology.